WattClear

The price that changes once the meter passes a line

By DueRiva · Published · Updated · Figures from data retrieved

104 of the 242 published plans a household can take charge a different price for a kilowatt-hour once the meter passes a threshold the tariff sets. The median step is 5.5¢ — but crossing it does not settle what a bill costs per kilowatt-hour, because a fixed monthly charge is pulling the other way. On 43 of those 104 plans the heavier household still pays more per kilowatt-hour than the lighter one; on the 138 plans without bands, 0 do.

What a tier actually is

A tiered plan divides the month into bands. The first so many kilowatt-hours are billed at one price, the next at another, and the meter starts again at zero next month. The bands are published in the tariff, which is why this page can state the step in cents rather than infer it from a bill.

More ladders climb than fall: of the 104 tiered plans here, 74 rise, 21 fall and 9 move both ways depending on the season or the hour. A rising ladder prices a large household’s last kilowatt-hour highest, the opposite of most things bought in bulk; a falling ladder, a declining block, does the reverse and bills the heaviest use cheapest.

The step, utility by utility

One row per utility, at the largest step it publishes. A company that files the same ladder for each region it serves publishes it many times over; listing every filing would fill the table with one company’s variants.

The largest step between two bands, by utility
UtilityPlanBandsStep atStep500 → 2000 kWh
Residential - Schedule R
3
30 kWh
+14.9¢19.8¢ → 19.2¢
A Residential Standard Offer Service (Bundled)
2
50 kWh
+13.6¢31.0¢ → 27.5¢
TOU-DR Coastal Baseline Regionand 15 more tiered plans
2
270 kWhdaily allowance
+10.7¢50.2¢ → 51.0¢
Domestic Service: D - Baseline Region 10and 8 more tiered plans
3
363 kWhdaily allowance
+9.6¢35.5¢ → 41.1¢
E-1 -Residential Service Baseline Region Pand 19 more tiered plans
3
405 kWhdaily allowance
+8.1¢39.7¢ → 40.4¢
Residential Service
2
600 kWh
+6.9¢19.8¢ → 20.8¢
SCHEDULE R-30 RESIDENTIAL SERVICE
3
650 kWh
+6.5¢16.6¢ → 16.1¢
1A (Residential Service)
3
450 kWh
+5.6¢16.7¢ → 19.9¢
Residential Service Secondary Non-Transmitting Meter Rate (RSM)
2
600 kWh
+5.4¢24.6¢ → 24.5¢
RS - Residential Service
3
300 kWh
−5.1¢19.6¢ → 14.7¢
Residential Peak Adjustment Service (Schedule RPKA)and 1 more tiered plan
3
600 kWh
−4.7¢15.5¢ → 11.4¢
Rate 10: Residential Electric
5
1,200 kWh
−4.3¢18.7¢ → 14.2¢
1(M) Residential Evening/Morning Saver Serviceand 1 more tiered plan
2
750 kWh
−3.4¢14.8¢ → 12.1¢
Residential
4
2,000 kWh
+3.4¢14.0¢ → 13.5¢
Schedule 1 (Residential Service - Single Phase, single family)
2
400 kWh
+3.3¢13.7¢ → 13.7¢
DS-1 Residential Zone 3and 1 more tiered plan
2
800 kWh
−3.1¢48.6¢ → 45.3¢
SC-1 - Residential & Religious Service - Zone J [NYC]and 3 more tiered plans
2
250 kWh
+2.4¢41.2¢ → 38.5¢
Residential Service
2
1,000 kWh
−2.3¢15.6¢ → 13.0¢
SCHEDULE R RESIDENTIAL SERVICE - Single Phase
3
1,200 kWh
+2.3¢39.3¢ → 38.6¢
RS-1 Residential Service
2
1,000 kWh
+2.0¢14.4¢ → 13.8¢
Residential Electric Service TRRES (Single Phase)and 1 more tiered plan
3
500 kWh
+2.0¢17.3¢ → 15.6¢
Residential Service
3
1,500 kWh
+2.0¢16.8¢ → 15.0¢
7 (Residential Service - Single Phase)
2
600 kWh
+1.9¢20.8¢ → 21.0¢
Residential Electric Service (RES-25)
2
800 kWh
−1.9¢12.6¢ → 10.8¢
RS-1 Residential Service
2
1,000 kWh
+1.8¢16.6¢ → 15.5¢
RS Residential Electric
2
1,000 kWh
+1.8¢15.2¢ → 13.2¢
Cuivre River Electric Coop IncMissouri
Residential
2
800 kWh
−1.7¢15.8¢ → 10.6¢
RS (Residential Standard Service)
3
900 kWh
−1.5¢14.0¢ → 11.5¢
DTE ElectricMichigan
Residential Service Rate - (Full Service) - D1
2
17 kWh
+1.3¢24.7¢ → 23.3¢
Family Dwelling Service
2
750 kWh
−1.2¢17.7¢ → 14.8¢
RS - Residential - over 325 KWH per month
2
500 kWh
−1.2¢18.4¢ → 14.9¢
Southwestern Electric Power Co (Texas)Texas
Residential Service
2
600 kWh
−1.1¢13.7¢ → 11.9¢
Residential Service (GMO)
3
1,000 kWh
+1.1¢14.6¢ → 11.8¢
Residential Service - Single Phase
2
800 kWh
−1.0¢17.9¢ → 15.1¢
Residential Service (RES-55) Single Phase
2
800 kWh
−1.0¢17.5¢ → 15.4¢
Residential Service Single Phase (RS-40C)
2
500 kWh
−0.8¢16.3¢ → 10.9¢
Residential Service (Rate 7)
2
2,000 kWh
+0.8¢21.6¢ → 19.1¢
Residential - RS (SC)
2
1,000 kWh
+0.7¢15.8¢ → 14.4¢
110 Residential Service
3
100 kWh
−0.7¢16.1¢ → 11.5¢
A - Residential Service
3
650 kWh
−0.7¢15.0¢ → 10.8¢
8 (Residential Service)and 1 more tiered plan
2
800 kWh
−0.6¢19.6¢ → 18.3¢
Residential Service
2
600 kWh
+0.5¢14.3¢ → 13.1¢
City of Huntsville, Alabama (Utility Company)Alabama
Schedule RS - Residential
2
1,400 kWh
+0.5¢14.4¢ → 11.9¢
Residential Schedule 1
2
800 kWh
+0.3¢17.8¢ → 16.1¢
RS Standard Residential Rate
2
500 kWh
−0.1¢17.4¢ → 15.0¢
Residential Time-of-Day Bundled Ohio Power Rate Zone (RS-TOD)and 2 more tiered plans
3
15,000 kWh
−0.1¢20.0¢ → 17.7¢
RS (Residential Service)
3
15,000 kWh
−0.1¢27.3¢ → 26.0¢
The step is measured inside one period — the one publishing the most bands — because a time-of-use plan prices each period on its own ladder, and two of them can run in opposite directions. Thresholds published as a daily allowance are shown for a 30-day month; the rate engine uses the real length of each billing month. The last column is what the whole bill works out at per kilowatt-hour at the lightest and heaviest rung, fixed charges included. A further 3 utilities publish bands priced identically within a period, moving the price between seasons instead; they have a ladder but no step to cross by using more.

Why the bill can still get cheaper per kilowatt-hour

A tier raises the price of the next kilowatt-hour. A fixed monthly charge does the opposite to the average: it is the same whether the household buys 500 kWh or 2,000 kWh, so it spreads thinner the more the meter records. Which force wins is a question about a particular plan, and the answer here is close to even.

On 43 of the 104 tiered plans — 41% — the whole bill costs more per kilowatt-hour at 2,000 kWh a month than at 500 kWh. On the 138 plans with no bands, that is true of 0. Tiers are what make the exception; they do not guarantee it.

Potomac Electric Power Co’s Residential - Schedule R shows both at once: a step of 14.9¢ at 30 kWh, and a whole bill that moves from 19.8¢ to 19.2¢ a kilowatt-hour between the two rungs.

Where the threshold comes from

45 of the tiered plans here publish their threshold as a daily allowance rather than a monthly one. California writes them that way: a baseline quantity per day, multiplied by the length of the billing month, and set differently for each climate zone and season. A household in one region of a utility’s territory therefore crosses into the dearer band at a different point from a household in another, on the same schedule.

That is why the threshold column is a single number for a plan that may publish several, and why the figures on this site are attributed to the record they came from. The utility pages list every band of every plan they price.

The plans that get cheaper as they climb

What this page does not tell you

It does not say which plan is cheaper for a particular household. A band structure only matters alongside the consumption it is billed against, and the figures here are priced at three fixed levels rather than at yours. The rate comparator prices every plan a utility publishes at a consumption you enter.

Nor does it price an appliance. A tier means the cost of running one depends on what the rest of the household has already used that month — a dryer on a plan whose band has already been crossed is billed at the dearer price, not at the bill’s average. That is the calculation behind the cost-to-run pages, which price each appliance as the difference it makes to a real bill rather than as watts times an average rate.

Taxes are not included, and consumption is spread evenly across the month. A household that uses the same total unevenly crosses its bands sooner in the heavier months, which moves a tiered bill and leaves a flat one where it was.

More guides

How this page was made

Every figure here is computed when the site is built, from the records named below, by the same code that fills the state, utility and cost-to-run pages this guide links to. When those records are refreshed, the figures change with them; the words around them do not, which is why no sentence here states a direction the data has not been checked for.

The methodology page sets out what the rate engine assumes and where its figures stop being reliable.